Choose the wrong Thai island at the wrong time of year and your dream holiday can mean torrential rain, packed beaches, or accidentally staying in the middle of a massive party. We have travelled Thailand on and off for three years and now we live here, and the biggest thing we have learnt is that every island suits a completely different kind of trip.
The confusing bit is the weather, because the best time of year on one side of Thailand can be the worst time on the other. So instead of ranking the islands, here are the seven we genuinely love, when we would go to each one, and the things that caught us out on the way.
Five things that caught us out
1The two coasts have opposite seasons
On the Andaman side, the west coast with Koh Lipe, Koh Phi Phi and Koh Lanta, the best weather runs from December to about March or April. Blue skies, almost no rain, and a lot more people, which you feel on islands this small. The shoulder months, November and April, bring fewer people and maybe a bit of rain, and we think that is a good trade.
The lower Gulf, Koh Phangan, Koh Tao and Koh Samui, runs on a different clock. The rain there comes from October to December and November is typically the worst month, often torrential the whole time. January to April is the best of it. From April to September you get short bursts of rain rather than all day rain, and it is very hot and humid. We filmed this in September on a stunning day.
Koh Kood breaks the pattern. It sits in the Gulf, but over near Koh Chang, and it follows the Andaman pattern: best from November to April, rainy from May to October. When Koh Phangan is at its wettest in November and December, Koh Kood is dry.
2We went to Koh Lipe in November and got half of it in the rain
Koh Lipe is one of our favourite islands in Thailand. It is so small there are no cars and you cannot even hire a scooter, you just walk from one side to the other. We went in November and had three lovely days, then four of torrential rain. The upside was that there was hardly anyone there. We would go again at the tail end of November, because December and especially January get very busy.
The food was a level above anything we expected, even for Thailand. Our favourite was Pirate Kitchen and its pirate salad, a cold, coconutty Thai style ceviche that was the best thing we ate on the whole trip. Walk down Walking Street and you will hear the man outside the 7-Eleven singing about his ten baht coconut doughnuts. The song will get stuck in your head, and you have to buy them.
Getting there was rough. We flew to Hat Yai and caught boats, and the water at that time of year was so rough that we felt quite unsafe. The boat from Koh Lanta was hectic too. If you do not like ferries, fly to Langkawi in Malaysia and take the one hour ferry across instead.
3We watched Maya Bay from the boat when we could have stood on it
Koh Phi Phi is busy, it was made famous by The Beach, and it is still stunning. Abbey has been three times and it feels busier and more of a party island each time. There are a lot of 18 to 25 year olds out partying. We were in bed by 8pm and still loved it, because it is so small you walk everywhere and can stay well clear of the parties.
The day trips are the reason to go, and Maya Bay is the big one. Book a private longtail the night before and ask to go before it opens. Ours cost 2,000 baht. You are not allowed to swim in the bay, so we sat in the boat watching from afar, pleased there was no one on the beach. We had no idea you could go round the back and walk through to stand on the sand. By the time we worked it out, people were already lining up. Be one of the first in, then run down for your photo.
4Koh Lanta is bigger and quieter than it looks from Phuket
Koh Lanta is the couples and families island. It is close to Phuket, so if you fly in there and want an island without a long trip, it could be the one. But it is big and spread out, with most of what happens on one side and no real hub town. The beaches are long, quiet stretches where you can always find a bar with hardly anyone in it. We found it lovely and relaxing, and also felt something was missing.
We would go back to Koh Lanta for Moon Massage alone. We have had somewhere between 50 and 100 massages in three years in Thailand, and this one is in our top three. It was being renovated when we went and they still squeezed a couple of people in through the back. Ask for the healing massage. When we recommend a massage it has to be good, and this one you just book.
5The quietest island has no gym and no cafe scene
Koh Kood is one of our favourite islands, and a lot of people never make it over there because it is on the other side of the Gulf. That is exactly why it is so quiet. When we drove around on the scooter there was hardly anyone on the road. White sand, blue water, beach shacks. It feels like Thailand 20 years ago.
The downside for us was training. When we went there was one really dodgy gym, and we do not remember finding a single cool cafe. If health and fitness matter on your holiday, Koh Kood is not the island for that. It is still where Tijs proposed to Abbey, over a dinner in the treetops where we were hoisted up in a basket and the food arrived by zip line.
The Gulf islands, for the other half of the year
Koh Phangan, north end only. It is known for the Full Moon Party, which happens down the south and spreads over a week or two. Stay up north and it is perfection: peaceful, quiet, great cafes, yoga and wellness. Our favourite day there is hiking down to Bottle Beach, the most beautiful beach on the island, and getting a longtail boat back.
Koh Tao, for diving. Another small island you do not need a scooter for, and the place to learn to dive. One of us did a PADI course here about ten years ago, and everyone says it is the cheapest place in Thailand to get certified. Everything sits along one walking strip on the beach. Hike up to a viewpoint where you can see Koh Samui and Koh Phangan, and take the small boat across to Koh Nang Yuan for a few drinks, which we did with friends.
Koh Samui, for everything. It is the most popular island for good reason: water sports, cafes, gyms, night markets, and an airport, which is basically why we chose to live here. Go to Chaweng if you want to party and steer clear of it if you do not. Bophut has the Fisherman's Village and its night market. We live in Lamai, which is more laid back, with a beautiful beach and the best gyms.
So, which one would we pick?
Decide the month first, then the island. December to April, go west to Koh Lipe, Koh Phi Phi or Koh Lanta. January to August, the Gulf is yours. November, our pick is Koh Kood, where we had perfect weather that month. And if you want a party and a quiet beach on the same trip, stay in the north of Koh Phangan.
If we had to name favourites, Koh Phangan comes first, then Koh Lipe, then Koh Kood. Ask us again after our first November living on Koh Samui.
Abbey & Tijs