Choosing between Koh Samui and Koh Phangan is harder than it looks on a map. They sit right next to each other in the Gulf of Thailand, and they feel like two completely different trips.
So we settled it the only fair way we could think of. Seven rounds, one point each: getting around, things to do, beaches, food, nightlife, training and cost. Then where to stay, because the wrong part of either island can fully make or break the trip.
Seven rounds, one island each
1Getting around goes to Samui, easily
Koh Samui has an airport, and that is a real winner for us. It is probably why we live here at the moment. Once you land it is a big island but an easy one, because Grab and Bolt both work. Both need data, so sort a Thailand eSIM before you fly (we earn from sales through this link).
Koh Phangan has no airport. From the mainland you usually catch two ferries, one to Samui and then another across, so it adds time. And on the island, if you do not want to ride a scooter, it is genuinely hard to get around. There is no Grab and the taxis cost a lot more.
2Samui has more to do, Phangan has the Full Moon
Samui is the bigger island and it has the activities to match: boat trips, jet skis, the Pig Island tour with a bar on the island, plus cinemas, a shooting range, beach clubs and even a mall.
Koh Phangan is smaller. There are tours and some stunning lookout hikes, but there is definitely no mall. What it does have is the Full Moon Party, once a month, with jungle parties all through the lead up. If your goal in Thailand is fun and parties, Phangan is your island.
One trip works from both islands: Ang Thong National Park. It is a must. A day trip takes you round a group of islands, and the main one has a viewpoint you climb up to over a pristine beach. They also let around 20 people a night camp there. We have not done it yet, and we really should next time.
3The beaches go to Phangan, and it is not close
Samui has fantastic beaches, but most of them are lined with resorts and restaurants, so in peak season they get really busy. Silver Beach is gorgeous and packed. Lamai, where we live, is a beautiful stretch of sand with plenty of resorts on it too.
Phangan has a more relaxed, almost hippie feel. Haad Yao and Haad Salad are long runs of white sand with barely a restaurant on them. Our favourite is Bottle Beach. You hike up to the lookout and back down, and it is the most pristine white sand with one beach shack on it. It is probably one of our favourite beaches, full stop.
4Food goes to Samui, for the variety
This one was hard. Samui has some of the best coffee, and the cafe we go to in Lamai roasts its own beans. The restaurant variety is huge, and the beach clubs and jungle clubs are on another level because the island simply has more space.
Phangan is more laid back and far less bougie, especially up north. Top Rock Bar is one of our favourite lookouts on the island, rustic and family owned by Thai people. If you want beach shack food, go Phangan. If you want variety, it is Samui.
5Nightlife goes to Phangan, no contest
The Full Moon Party is one of the biggest parties in the world. If we were doing it, we would stay near it, around Haad Rin in the south, so there is no taxi nightmare and no scooter ride home. Ban Tai, the main area nearby, is a good 35 minute drive away.
Samui parties too. Chaweng is a big nightclub district. But it is just not at that level, because on Phangan once you connect with people you find the little jungle parties everywhere. The first time we went we got into a secret party you could only reach by boat.
6Training goes to Samui, with one catch
We have lived on both and never been let down by the gyms. On Samui they are bigger and nicer, with pools and air con. On Phangan they are rustic and outdoors, and you can walk in without shoes. One of us did not wear shoes or a shirt for the whole six months, and loved it.
The catch: the Phangan gyms we used both had a sauna and an ice bath, and none of the gyms in Lamai do. On Samui we train at Samui Fitness Lab, which is great for high reps and classes, with a really good community and an air conditioned gym. For Muay Thai, both islands are fantastic.
7Cost is close, but Phangan rents cheaper
Honestly the two are close. A local meal out for two runs about 400 to 900 baht. Good mid range accommodation with air con is about 1,800 to 4,000 baht a night, and a scooter is around 200 to 400 baht a day. All up, plan on roughly 3,600 to 6,000 baht a day on either island.
Two things tip it. On Phangan, if you will not ride a scooter, the shared taxis cost at least 200 to 300 baht for a short trip, which is a rip-off. But every time we have rented there it has been cheaper, and a decent place at a good price is easier to find than on Samui.
Where we would stay
On Samui, Lamai. It is where we live. It is more chill, the beach is stunning, the gyms and cafes are great, and the traffic is lighter than Bophut, which is the pick if you want to be closer to the action. Stay in Chaweng only if you are there to party.
On Phangan, the north or the west. Chaloklum in the north is much quieter, and Haad Yao on the west coast is a really cool place to stay. Both are on the opposite side of the island from the Full Moon Party. If the party is the reason you are going, stay down south in Haad Rin.
Or both. The ferry between them is about 25 minutes. Base yourself on Samui, do a day trip or a night on Phangan, and fly out of Samui.
So which one?
Final score, four points to Koh Samui and three to Koh Phangan. If you are a family or you want an easy holiday, Samui is the choice, and you will never get that cabin fever feeling.
But we love Phangan for that small island feel. It is laid back, a little less busy, the beaches are beautiful and it just feels more authentic. The vibe of each island is so different that we would try to do both.
Abbey & Tijs