We made a confident call on Instagram before we had set foot on either island. If you want a European summer without the crowds, we said, skip Mallorca and go to its neighbour Menorca instead. Same Mediterranean feel, white sand and crystal blue water, far fewer people and a fraction of the cost. In another reel we called Menorca just as beautiful, a lot smaller and almost half the price.
Then in October 2026 we actually went, four days on Mallorca and then two on Menorca. Tijs kept saying we were in Mallorca when we were in Menorca, which tells you how alike the names are. The islands themselves are very different places, and this is how our pre-trip advice held up.
What held up, and what caught us out
1Quieter and more local: true
One of us said it on camera within a day, I think I prefer Menorca. It is much quieter and it has more of a local feel, although some places definitely feel touristy. The owner of one lunch spot told us Ciutadella is the perfect town for families, super safe, with kids walking themselves to school. Most people around us were families or older couples, so we believed him.
The biggest difference for us was walking. On Mallorca we spent the first two days in the hills, where you cannot really walk anywhere, and the roads are narrow and full of cyclists. On Menorca a path ran from our apartment down to the beach and along the coast all the way into Ciutadella, past little coves. One of them is Cala en Brut, a famous one with no sand at all, just rocks you dive off and then lie on in the sun.
2Cheaper: true for where we slept
Our Menorca base was a three bedroom apartment about 15 minutes out of Ciutadella, with a shared pool, a small gym with a chin-up bar, a washing machine and that path to the water. For what we paid it was very, very reasonable.
Compare that with Mallorca, where we could not find the cheaper tier of accommodation we usually find in Sardinia or Greece, and where we put a mid-range hotel at 200 to 400 euro a night. Eating out on Menorca was not cheap either, but at our second tapas stop a lamb shoulder was only about 25 euro, the first time all trip we had found a big piece of meat for under 100 euro.
3Menorca shuts at 3pm, and in October it is about to shut for the year
Ciutadella is a really cute town to explore for the day, but most places close from 3pm until 7:30 or 8pm for siesta. Come for breakfast or lunch, or come back late.
The bigger surprise was the season. Menorca is super seasonal, and when we were there in early October there was only about a week left before most things closed until next season. A week later and we would have found nothing open.
4The weather cancelled our lunch on both islands
On our first full day a message came through: the open-air island restaurant we had planned the whole day around was closing because of a rain forecast at midday. Exactly the same thing had happened to us on Mallorca, where a famous paella place cancelled the day before and the next day turned out perfect.
So we did a tapas crawl instead. The first stop, Primitiu in Ciutadella, was the better of the two: raw, lightly smoked prawns, tomatoes that tasted fully in season, and an owner who was so caring and obviously passionate about his food. He also recommended an authentic rice place in Maó, which is how we ended up at Arjau the next day for duck rice, lamb and a fish croquette that turned out to be our favourite of the whole Spain trip. Lunch was 10 out of 10.
What we would tell a friend going to Menorca
Fly into Maó, base in the west. Maó is the other main town and probably where you will land. The drive from near Ciutadella to Maó took us about 50 minutes to an hour, and it is an easy, cruisey drive, even in a Fiat 500.
Read the lines before you park. Parking in Ciutadella was a struggle. Green lines on the ground mean residents with a permit only, blue means you pay, and white means it is free.
The cave bar, with a deadline. Cova d'en Xoroi is a bar built into a cave on a cliff, one of the most unusual in Europe, and it is a big drop down. The afternoon session had a tight window to get in, roughly 2:30 to 3pm, so we raced there straight from lunch and made it. In October 2026 it was about 15 euro each at the door with a drink, or around 13.50 online, and the sunset session was 25 euro each. The sun came out the minute we walked in.
Pick your month. We had listed the Balearics among the places in Europe that are still warm in October. The afternoons we got were beautiful, but our honest advice after going is maybe not to come in October, because the weather is temperamental. You will love it either way.
So, Menorca or Mallorca?
Our pre-trip call mostly held up. Menorca was quieter, more local and easier on the wallet where we slept, and the coast walk alone sold it. Mallorca is more of a party island, with a big, fun city in Palma and some of the best food we had in Spain, at a price.
If you only have time for one and you want the crowds gone, go to Menorca, and go before October.
Abbey & Tijs