Before we went, Mallorca sat at number three on our list of places in Europe that are still warm in October, with the weather averaging around 24 degrees. So we booked mid-October, the tail end of the season, and Abbey did more research for this trip than Tijs had ever seen her do.
We came for the beaches, got about one sunny day, and somehow ordered a steak that cost almost 200 euro. The island is incredible, it is expensive, and it is very easy to get wrong. This is what we got wrong, what it really cost, and whether we think it is worth it.
Four things that caught us out
1Mid-October is a gamble
We stuffed the timing. The week we were there we had roughly one sunny day, the sunshine came out as we were leaving, and the week after us was all sun. Things were also starting to shut down for the season. You can still get fantastic weather in October, but it is a gamble.
We were told not to worry too much about the forecast, because it can be cloudy one moment and blue sky the next, and that it gets super hot from May right through to September. On our first afternoon it was about 22 degrees and overcast. If we planned it again we would go in May or September: stunning weather, a few less crowds, and probably the ideal time of year.
Even at the tail end of the season, the towns got really busy in the afternoon. Imagine it in high season.
2The weather cancels your restaurant, not just your beach day
The paella place we wanted most is right on the water, and you can only get there by boat or a 45 minute hike. We had a reservation. The day before, they cancelled on us because the forecast was terrible. The next day was one of the best of the trip, and we literally drove past it in the sun.
A lot of restaurants on these islands are outdoors, so they cancel when the forecast is bad, and it happened to us again on Menorca. Have a backup booked. Ours was Ca'n Costa near Valldemossa, a big, famous paella place where most of the other diners were Spanish, which is always a good sign. They bring out a massive pan, show it around, then serve you as many plates as you want. It was our first paella in Spain and it was top-notch.
3We stayed somewhere beautiful and in the wrong place
We started in a 400 year old farm stay about 20 or 30 minutes inland from Sóller, with olive trees, apple orchards and a reading room. It was so picturesque, and it was up a lot of winding roads. Getting anywhere meant narrow mountain roads and long drives, and plans that kept changing with the weather. We were also told not to drink the tap water there.
If you are not a confident driver, those roads would be really hard. They are also full of cyclists, because the island is hugely popular for cycling, and you have to stay two metres away from a cyclist when you overtake. Tijs did that every time and only got yelled at once.
Then we moved to Palma, the sun came out, and our one regret became obvious. We almost wish we had spent the whole trip there and hired a car to go exploring. In Palma you can get everywhere on foot, the beach is not a far drive, and there is so much to do. The other option we would take next time is Sóller, the cute town the old tram runs through, so you are close to things and not driving so much.
4The steak that cost almost 200 euro
On day one, jet lagged, we went to Ses Coves, a grill next to the caves at Campanet. You do not order a portion of steak there. You buy the whole rib, whatever it weighs, and it is priced by the kilo. Tijs asked how much it would weigh, did not get a straight answer, and ordered it anyway.
It came out at 1.4 kg, at 135 euro a kilo in October 2026. You do the maths. He was shocked for about half an hour, then got over it, because it was the best steak we had in Spain. The other half of us rated the whole lunch 12 out of 10, the smoked butter on the sourdough and the croquettes included. If you go, go in a group so the price gets split, and maybe see the caves first.
What it really cost, and the bits we would keep
The daily budget. These are the numbers we gave in our guide in October 2026, so check them before you go. A mid-range hotel was 200 to 400 euro a night, and we spent more than that. A glass of wine was 3 to 5 euro, a casual lunch for two 45 to 70 euro, and a basic dinner 80 to 110 euro. All up, if you are not cooking at home, plan on 400 to 600 euro a day for two people. When we were researching accommodation we could not find the cheaper range we usually find in Sardinia or Greece.
Hiring a car. You need one, and it was not that expensive, around 30 to 50 euro a day. We learned this one by trial and error. Booking online, they will want a deposit of around 2,000 euro, but you can search for cars that need no deposit. They cost a little more, you get full coverage, and on roads this narrow you will be glad not to worry about a scratch.
A cheap breakfast in the hills. Not everything costs a fortune. Hotel Corazón, an agriturismo near Sóller that a follower recommended, grows most of what it cooks. The eggs were 7 euro, the toast less than that, the sourdough was a whopper and the salad was epic. On a grey morning the view was still stunning.
Twelve seats in Palma. Little Jarana is a wine bar with about 12 seats and five chefs, and if you get the bar you watch them cook. The only sitting left was 9:45pm, which was too late for us, so we messaged them on WhatsApp to go on a waitlist, and the next day they offered us 8pm. Waitlists like that are one reason to keep data on. Ryvo has eSIM plans for Spain (we earn from sales through this link). Order the anchovies. It was a 10 out of 10 dinner.
The one beach we made it to. The weather kept us off most of them, but Cala Llombards was beautiful. We went in October and it was still pretty busy, so in peak season get there by nine or ten in the morning to park. Beyond that, the island is full of coves that look a lot alike, cliffs and crystal blue water, so check a road goes to one and you will probably have it to yourself.
So, is Mallorca worth it?
It is probably one of the most expensive places in Europe we have ever been to, and it was beautiful and definitely worth it. If you are going on holiday you are there to spend money anyway, so save up, go, and enjoy it.
One honest footnote. Before the trip we told you to go to Menorca instead, for a European summer without the crowds, and said the island next door was just as beautiful at around half the price. After four days on Mallorca and two on Menorca, one of us said it out loud on camera: I think I prefer Menorca. Mallorca is more of a party island. If your budget is tight, that is the island we would look at first.
Abbey & Tijs