Everyone told us Siargao was the best surf island in the world. It is one of the most hyped surf destinations in Southeast Asia, and we did not leave unscathed.
One morning at Cloud 9, Tijs took a fin to the ear and we ended up in hospital. Honestly, that was not even the most surprising thing about the place. The longer we stayed, the more complicated our feelings got.
We were obsessed at first. Siargao felt like a mix of Asia and Costa Rica, and the modern restaurants and cafes surprised us. This is how two weeks turned that around, and the bits we would still go back for.
Five things that caught us out
1Tijs's first wave ended in hospital
Cloud 9 is one of the most famous surf breaks in the world. You walk out along the pier, go down the stairs and jump into the reef break. On his very first wave, Tijs was hit by his own board. A fin to the ear, not the reef.
A couple of locals spotted us straight away and pointed us to the first aid tent set up for the surf comp. It was a small thing, but it was genuinely kind, and it was the first real warmth we had felt from anyone since we arrived. The medic there said the cartilage was split and she was not trained to stitch it, so we headed for the main hospital in Dapa, about 25 minutes away.
The hospital did not have everything it needed, so Abbey had to go and hunt down the supplies at the pharmacy herself. And in the rush we paid a tuk tuk 1,000 pesos on that trip in April and May 2026, when the standard fare around General Luna was 50 to 150.
Learn from it. Cloud 9 is at its best at mid to high tide, when the wave shape is better and the reef is not sitting as shallow underneath you, so check the tide times before you paddle out.
2General Luna is not cheap
Tourism exploded here after the pandemic and prices followed. Restaurants, accommodation and even basic supplies are priced for visitors, and it has pushed a lot of locals out of their own town. By Philippine standards, General Luna is expensive.
We were saving for a villa in Sri Lanka, so one day we set ourselves 2,000 pesos to live on. We blew it by 536 pesos, mostly on a second coffee and entry fees.
Our tiny loft cost about 1,100 Australian dollars for the two weeks in April and May 2026. Awesome wifi and a desk, but squishy for two, with no outdoor area and not many restaurants in walking distance. If we did it again we would book something bigger, up near Cloud 9. If your stay's wifi lets you down, Ryvo has eSIM plans for the Philippines (we earn from sales through this link).
3The vibe felt off
Service in General Luna is hit and miss. Sometimes it is fantastic and other times you get completely ignored, so you need thick skin. We walked into a pharmacy with three staff, said hello, and none of them even looked at us, and we were the only customers. At one lunch spot we stood waiting to be seated while three staff looked straight through us.
We had a lot of negative interactions, with locals and with other travellers, and we could never quite get in on the vibe. It was patchier than that, though. The right person, the right place and the right part of the island felt completely different, which made us wonder whether we had just stayed in the wrong spot.
4The rain had its own ideas
Siargao has a different rainy season to the rest of the Philippines, and most people make the mistake of going in December to February. We arrived at the end of April, which is not technically rainy season. It was sunny one minute and pouring the next, and one week it rained so much we were confused.
Plan for March to October, with the bigger surf from around August to November. And if rain is coming on the day you want to explore the north, hire a car or a jeep instead of a scooter.
5The famous spots were not the best ones
Coconut Road, the palm-lined Instagram spot, was an anticlimax. It looks very Instagram worthy, then you get there and it is kind of not it. We kept driving and found an emptier stretch of palms that was even better.
At the rock pools in the north, a crowd came rushing towards us. For a second it looked like they were coming for us. They were fans of famous Filipino actors filming a movie. The pools only exist when the tide is out, which is exactly when everyone else turns up, so check the tide times online before you drive out.
Same with food. The restaurant everyone recommended was beautiful, charged accordingly and left us hungry. A barbecue place we found afterwards cost about a tenth as much and was twice as good, which is sort of Siargao in a sentence.
The bits we would keep exactly the same
The north. The north is 100 percent better than the south for us. It is way more chill, the surf is sick, there are hardly any people, and the people are nicer. Tijs surfed Pacifico and had the waves pretty much to himself, and Abbey had her first ever scooter lesson on the quiet roads up there and loved it. There is no gym in the north, and it is a good 45 minutes from General Luna, but we kind of wish we had stayed up there.
Breakfast with a view. North Dirty Kitchen, up near Pacifico, is open air, with surfers coming off the water and a view that is impossible to beat. Get the surfers plate.
The food. The food scene is one of Siargao's strongest suits. CEV surprised us the most, a ceviche bar where you order the Pacifico and the spring rolls stuffed with fish, and you should book about a week ahead or face a long wait. Wild is our pick for Filipino comfort food, rich slow cooked adobo pork with the buns on the side.
The coffee. We tried about nine coffee spots, and most were fine with forgettable service. Saint Thomas Coffee stood out. It is tucked away and easy to miss, it had the best coffee on the island, and the staff made us feel like they actually wanted us there.
The routine. PrimeFit Gym in General Luna was our gym for the two weeks. To save money we lived off roast chickens, which are everywhere, plus veggies from the store every day, and it was the best roast chook we have had anywhere in three years.
So, should you go to Siargao?
If you are a surfer, yes, genuinely. Cloud 9 is world class. For an island holiday we would think twice. The vibe in General Luna is off, and Siargao is not the place everyone makes it out to be.
We meant to stay a month and left after two weeks. Part of that was the 2026 fuel crisis: we cut the trip short in case flights were cancelled, and our flight out was cancelled the day after we booked it. Part of it was that we did not love it. If we had stayed only in the north, we probably would have.
Abbey & Tijs